Difference between revisions of "RE-I2 "Skiff" Liquid Fuel Engine"

Latest revision as of 18:58, 31 October 2023

Available only with the Making History Expansion installed.

RE-I2 "Skiff" Liquid Fuel Engine
Liquid fuel engine by Rockomax Conglomerate
Radial size		Large, Radial mounted
Cost	(total)	2 300.00
Mass	(total)	1.600 t
Drag		0.3-0.2
Max. Temp.		2000 K
Impact Tolerance		7 m/s
Research		Heavier Rocketry
Unlock cost		9 200
Since version		1.4.1
Part configuration		LiquidEngineRE-I2.cfg
Maximum thrust	(1 atm)	240.91 kN
	(vacuum)	300.00 kN
Isp	(1 atm)	265 s
	(vacuum)	330 s
Fuel consumption		18.54 /s
Thrust vectoring		2 °
Electricity generated		3.0 ⚡/s
Testing Environments
On the surface		Yes
In the ocean		Yes
On the launchpad		Yes
In the atmosphere		Yes
Sub-orbital		Yes
In an orbit		Yes
On an escape		Yes
Docked		No
Test by staging		Yes
Manually testable		Yes
Packed volume		None

The RE-I2 "Skiff" Liquid Fuel Engine is a relatively light and versatile 2.5m or 1.875m sustainer-type liquid fuel engine.

Usage

The Skiff is average or above average in each metric of engine performance. It is inexpensive and lightweight, it has thrust vectoring, and its thrust-to-weight ratio and specific impulse are both good (but not exceptional), both in atmosphere and in vacuum.

It does not excel in any single category; in some ways it is a "Jack of all trades, master of none." In rockets that solely use serial staging, for each of those stages, it is likely that another more specialized engine will outperform the Skiff. But when using parallel staging i.e. boosters, especially with fuel crossfeed enabled, the Skiff's versatility can give good performance at launch, after booster separation, and in orbit. This may allow for reducing the number of engines, thus reducing the cost and dry mass of the rocket.

As the lightest 2.5m engine, the Skiff can be useful for transporting relatively light but wide payloads which would be awkward or impossible to fit in smaller fairing sizes, like some small landers. Its combination of atmospheric and vacuum performance also make it competitive for operation in thin atmospheres like Duna's, as an alternative to vacuum-oriented engines or a more expensive cluster of Darts.

The Skiff slots between the two most closely comparable engines, the Swivel and the Skipper. Relative to the Swivel, the Skiff gives 40% more thrust for less than 7% more weight, with better efficiency both in atmosphere and in vacuum. The Skipper gives more than double the thrust for 88% more mass, and improves on the Skiff's specific impulse in atmosphere, but comes with a correspondingly higher price and slightly lower efficiency in vacuum.

Product description

Variants

As of version 1.4.1 this engine has two models that can be switched in the editor. The Shrouded variant is radial size large, while the Bare variant is size medium.

The different variants of the engine

Trivia

Real-world comparison

The Skiff was inspired by the American J-2 engine, used for both the second and third stages of the Saturn V.

Though the Skiff's vacuum efficiency is slightly above average, it isn't high enough to make the claim in the product description very convincing. In particular, Making History also includes the Wolfhound, which is far more efficient in vacuum and also has higher thrust, but is twice as heavy. The Wolfhound was modeled after the Apollo Service Propulsion System, which was the next stage of Apollo missions after the third stage's J-2, and had a much lower mass and specific impulse than the efficient and powerful J-2. So some forum users speculated that perhaps Squad simply mistakenly swapped the two engines' stats, and the Skiff should have been the heavier, high-I_sp engine. However, Squad stated their intention was to make the Apollo SPS analogue a vacuum-specific engine, and swapped stats would still leave both engines quite different from their Apollo counterparts.

The differences only affect realism, especially when trying to build and fly a replica Apollo mission. Both parts were significantly adjusted for gameplay balance in version 1.6.

In-Game Similarities

The RE-I2 engine has an uncanny resemblance to the single bell variant of the RE-L10 "Poodle" Liquid Fuel Engine. It is unknown if this is intentional or not.

Changes

1.6

• Increased unlock cost from 4500 to 9200
• Increased cost from 1500 to 2300
• Increased mass from 1 to 1.6
• Increased crash tolerance from 6 to 7

1.4.5

• Added ModuleTestSubject

1.4.1

• Initial Release